Best hotel loyalty program
The short answer
The best hotel loyalty program is the one with hotels where you travel. On the rules alone: Hyatt has the most predictable award prices, with a published chart. Hilton is the easiest to climb, with stays and spend routes to status. IHG’s points never expire once you’re elite. Marriott, with more than 10,000 properties by its own count, gives every member the fifth night free on points. We cover Marriott Bonvoy in depth; the other three are summarized from their own pages.
- 4
- programs compared, from their own rules
- 24 months
- the expiry window at Marriott, Hilton and Hyatt
- 1
- program with a published award chart: Hyatt
01
Marriott, Hilton, Hyatt and IHG side by side
| Marriott Bonvoy | Hilton Honors | World of Hyatt | IHG One Rewards | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Elite tiers, nights a year | Silver 10, Gold 25, Platinum 50, Titanium 75, Ambassador 100 | Silver 10, Gold 25, Diamond 50, Diamond Reserve 80 | Discoverist 10, Explorist 30, Globalist 60 | Silver Elite 10, Gold Elite 20, Platinum Elite 40, Diamond Elite 70 |
| Base points per US$1 | 10 at most brands | See the program's site | 5 (2.5 at Hyatt Studios) | 10 at most brands (5 at Staybridge Suites and Candlewood Suites) |
| Free night on longer points stays | Fifth night free, every member | Fifth night free on Standard Room Rewards, for Silver and above | Not a program rule | Every fourth Reward Night free, for holders of the IHG Chase cards |
| Award prices | Vary by hotel, room, length of stay and season | See the program's site | A published chart by hotel category, with off-peak, standard and peak prices | See the program's site |
| Points expire | After 24 months without activity | After 24 consecutive months without activity | After 24 consecutive months of inactivity | Never for elite members; after 12 months without activity at Club level |
02
The best program for each kind of traveler
- Short, frequent trips: Hilton, where 25 stays reach Diamond without 50 nights.
- Planning around a points price: Hyatt, whose chart shows the cost before you search.
- A balance you rarely touch: IHG elite members, whose points don’t expire.
- Long stays on points, anywhere: Marriott, where five award nights cost four for every member, with no status needed. Find five-night stays.
03
Why comparing points per dollar misleads
Marriott and IHG earn 10 base points per dollar at most brands, Hyatt 5. That doesn’t rank them: each program’s points buy a different amount of hotel. Compare the points price of the same kind of stay, and its cash rate, in each program. For Marriott, we rate every stay by value per point. How we rate a stay.
04
Program against program
- Marriott vs Hilton: status routes, breakfast and the fifth night.
- Marriott vs Hyatt: an award chart against prices that move.
- Marriott vs IHG: points that never expire, and a card’s fourth night free.
05
Join more than one
All four are free to join, and plenty of travelers belong to two: one for status, one for the hotels status doesn’t cover. Put your status where you stay most, and book the rest wherever the stay is best value. How Marriott Bonvoy works.
Questions
What is the best hotel loyalty program?
The one with hotels where you travel. Hyatt has the most predictable award prices, Hilton the easiest status, IHG points that never expire for elites, and Marriott the fifth night free for every member.
Which hotel program has an award chart?
Of the four, only Hyatt publishes one, with off-peak, standard and peak prices by hotel category.
Which hotel points don't expire?
IHG points don't expire for elite members. Marriott, Hilton and Hyatt points expire after 24 months without activity.
Which hotel program gives a free night on points stays?
Marriott gives every member the fifth night free on standard awards. Hilton gives a fifth night free to Silver and above. IHG gives every fourth night free to its Chase cardholders.
More on how Bonvoy works
Sources: Marriott Bonvoy terms, Hilton Honors tiers and benefits, World of Hyatt tiers and benefits, IHG One Rewards member terms. Program rules change, so confirm with Marriott before you rely on one. Award Escape is independent of Marriott.